No I agree woth Rukna. Prof cant be strict on some rules and lenient on others. so dogg is cheating, give him a warning and if he continues suspend his account.

__________________________
Leader of US Confederation
Freedom is not free.

14:24:50 | Vigilante planet Rouge II has been captured by Frost Monarch, IDG Elite Force.
14:24:50 | Vigilante has been defeated by Frost Monarch.
23:15:26 | nineyII planet RememberTheP

Psspp haha thats the funniset thing i ever heard in this game.. neggy ur a real comic.. mr suspension just wants to get me suspended when i HAV iiris permission and am doing nothing wrong. so none of ur business

um I clearly said, give you a warning and if you did it again then to suspend you. Dont blame me when the SL community sees what you did as cheating. I am not for suspending anybody, but principles are principles and Prof either needs to take action or clarify this new rule about extra harvesting planets. Simple, now if you want to act liek a little girl and say that I just want you suspended well then go ahead, because that shows that you are about as intellectual as a rock.

__________________________
Leader of US Confederation
Freedom is not free.

14:24:50 | Vigilante planet Rouge II has been captured by Frost Monarch, IDG Elite Force.
14:24:50 | Vigilante has been defeated by Frost Monarch.
23:15:26 | nineyII planet RememberTheP

yea thats a great insult and btw im not harvesting, hes is just holding so i can capture chains then i capture back.. so ur wrong.. and i hav the permission of them

Like I said, Professor needs to clarify what exactly the rules are so we dont have confusion and people getting suspended for things that they didnt know were illegal. That is all I am saying. I did not know you had permission and niether ddid anyone esle, so frankly it was our business, if we thought you were cheating or not. I know for damn sure that if it was i in your shoes you would be pounding questions up my a$$ wondering if I was getting an unfair advantage in the game so do not tell anyone in this game its not thier business, we all have proven that everything that pertains to the allegation of cheating is everyones business.

__________________________
Leader of US Confederation
Freedom is not free.

14:24:50 | Vigilante planet Rouge II has been captured by Frost Monarch, IDG Elite Force.
14:24:50 | Vigilante has been defeated by Frost Monarch.
23:15:26 | nineyII planet RememberTheP

And actually there are words "with or without permission" in Professor post
And i see many don't understand harvesting if you think it's throwing planets to inactives. Contralily, it is throwing planets to actives, just with a lack of planets, that ensures players won't oblit them when got. I used to throw them to yugo, kingzig, dagdamor - they all seemed to be too active and harvested from my planets
State radio, kerstas contrarily soon went inactive forever
LTC didn't make any important advantage from this tactic. It was much more fun than profit.

I don't understand that forbiding. It's not LTC problem if others can not take care of their planets and those who are dissapointed of it can not help those players to do that. LTC feel sore hearing from Professor we were cheating.

Definetely, it has to be monitored. As well as piracy. Cheating is if one player knows too passwords and shares the resources by using planets or ships - that has to be monitored. Would be nice if players with only 3 stars or even higher could make planet accepting only. It's not a necessity. Noobs can get coords or resources from helpers in spite of planets.

__________________________
I will defeat you. When you grow up, if you still feel raw about it, i'll be waiting.

The reason why it was stopped (other than it being a cheap tactic in my opinion) is that it is easily exploitable. Get a friend to sign up, planet accepting on, give him planets with gathering iron, then get him to log on next week and you take all planets and get loads of res

__________________________
Founder and Lord Admiral of The Legendary Swarm.

Go For It.

I agree. Therefore it has to be monitored and a limitation of points, stars or etc should be implemented to have the ability of planet accepting. I consider it would be hard to find such friend which having 3 or more stars would want to go to the shadow by giving you those resources. Staying alive for so long takes many efforts - he will want to play himself after such period

Actually i have nothing against forbiding harvesting. But Professor post is not helping here. Recapturing is usefull in many ways, no it is forbidden. And watupdogg surely broke that forbiding. Professor is in favour of him, so i hope my notice will attract Professor attention to this issue we have.

__________________________
I will defeat you. When you grow up, if you still feel raw about it, i'll be waiting.

runka the point is i am not cheating.. even ask iiri when i giv him the planets i put the shield up so nothing gathers. I just do this when i hav a long chain and hav a planet limit. there are going to be changes that when u giv the planet to another player the shield goes up anyway. so how is wat im doing wrong when im not gaining anything from it.. its just like leaving my planets to sp, except with no defense.

I don't even want to say you are cheating. You are doing nothing wrong. But according to Professor post it is forbidden to take the planets back with or without other player permission.

__________________________
I will defeat you. When you grow up, if you still feel raw about it, i'll be waiting.